The Practice of Medical Referral: Ethical Concerns

Anyanwu E. B.^1, , Abedi Harrison O.² and Onohwakpor Efe A.²

¹Department of Family Medicine, Delta State University Teaching Hospital, Oghara, Oghara, Nigeria

²Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Delta State University Teaching Hospital, Oghara, Oghara, Nigeria

Cite this paper

Anyanwu E. B., Abedi Harrison O. and Onohwakpor Efe A.. The Practice of Medical Referral: Ethical Concerns. American Journal of Public Health Research. 2015; 3(1):31-35. doi: 10.12691/AJPHR-3-1-5

Abstract

Medical referral is the act of sending a patient by one professional care giver to another, who may be a specialist and therefore be more knowledgeable in the diagnosing and further management of the patient. Most cases of referral of patients is therefore for proper diagnosis, adequate investigations and their proper treatment by the receiving specialists. It is mostly assumed and believed that patients depend on the medical information available to their health care providers. Therefore, the need for a referral, its appropriatness, timing and to whom the referral is made to mostly depends on the attending physician. This should be done after due consultation with the patients family and appropriate consent obtained. It is believed that a health practitioner should make a referral when he thinks that it will be of benefit to the patient and not when he wants to avoid the challenges of unraveling the patients’ complex problems. Also, referral should not be made to avoid possible death of the patient in a hospital so as not to worsen its statistics. Unfortunately, the seemingly good intention of referring of patients may cause a conflict of interests when physicians because of inherent financial gains refer patients to facilities that they own or have investment interest in. Such referral challenges as self-referral, and fee-splitting whereby a fee is paid to one physician by another for a referral is unethical, and are known to occur. Several “Anti-referral Laws” have subsequently been set up to prevent such actions and protect patients against abuse by health workers.

Keywords

patients, physicians, treatment, ethics, diagnosis

Copyright

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References

[1]	Referral (Medicine). Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Accessed 16/10/2013.
[2]	Nunez, 0., Cart-al, W., Hopkins, M., and Southall, D. Ethical Systems within Hospitals. In: International Child Health Care. A Practical Manual for Hospital Worldwide. Child Advocacy International. Eds: Southall, D., Coulter, B., Ronald, C., Nicholson, S., and Park, S. BMJ. 2002 pp. 12-15.
[3]	Opinion 8.132 - Referral of patients: Disclosure of Limitations. AMA (American Medical Association) Code of Ethics. http://www. ama.assn .org//ama/pub/physician-resources/medical ethics/code-medical-ethics/opinion8 1 32.pdf Accessed 16/10/2013.
[4]	Benjamin R. Physician’s Self-Referral. Report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs (Resolution 17, A - 07) CEJA Report 1-1-08. www.ama.assn.org/resources/doc/code-medical-ethics/8032/a.pdf Accessed 16/10/2013.
[5]	Huang, C. The Ethox Centre. Ethical Issues arising in individual Patient referrals http://www.ethox.org.uk.ethox-blog/ethical-issues-arising-in-individual patient-referrals Accessed 16/10/2013.
[6]	Sledge, S. K,, and Pierson, H. A. (1992). The Law provides patients with a little more protection. Silicon Valley Business Journal http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/stories/1998/02/02/ focus2html? pages all Accessed 16/10/2013.
[7]	Harris, S. M. (2008). Pay for referrals may be illegal as well as unethical. American Medical News http://www.amednews.com/article/20081117/business/3 11179998/5/. Accessed 16/10/2013.
[8]	Harper, B., and Reuter, S. (2009) Paying Fees to referring physicians Ethical or Not Ethical? Monitor (2009) pg 29-34. Clinicalperformancepartners.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07 physicians-referral-fee-final-ACRP-monitor 2009.pdf Accessed 16/10/2013.
[9]	Sanadi, E. N. (2011) Physician referral: Laws, Rules and Ethics. The Florida Bar www.floridarbar.org/.../110920%2ODr%2OEI%20sanadi’s%2ophysician%20 referral%20presentation.pdf Accessed 25/10/2013.
[10]	Kickback and Physician Self-referral Fraud/Office of Inspector General http://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/enforcement/cmp/kickback. asp.
[11]	Chetcuti, K., Farrugia, R. and Cassar, K. (2009) GP referral letters: time for a template? Malta Medical Journal Vol. 21 Issue 02, June 2009 pg 26-29
[12]	General Guidelines for Referring Dental Patients (2007) American Dental Association Council on Dental Practice www.ada.org/sections/.../pdfs/referring_guidlines.pdf Accessed 25/10/2013.
[13]	Slater, D. Y., (2011) The American Occupational Therapy Association Advisory Opinion for the Ethics Commission. Ethical Considerations in Private Practice www.aota.org/.../ethics/.../April%202013%20for%20posting% 20reformatted%20%2. Accessed 25/10/2013.
[14]	Goodell, M. A., and Casalino, L. P., (2008) Physician self-referral and physician-owned specialty facilities. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The Synthesis Project Policy Brief No. 15 (2008) www.rwjf.org/content/dam/farm/Reports/issue_briefs/2008 /rwjf28861 Accessed 25/10/2013.
[15]	The Surprising Secrets behind Doctor Referrals. Market watch http://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-surprising-secrets-behind-doctor referrals- 1334332558571. Accessed 25/10/2013.